Warli in Dharavi


Image of big city life in Warli style: Sion road, Dharavi

The presence of tribal communities in the Mumbai Metropolital region is not so well-known. Warlis, Kathkaris, Thakkars, Bhils are some of the many forest linked communities that are as integral to the peripheral landscape of the city as are industries and concrete developments. The fact that Mumbai encompasses both, the most densely populated neighbourhoods in the world, along with a natural tropical forest within its municipal limits, is also a counter-intuitive complement to this story.

While Warli art has become as gentrified as an art gallery in a heritage urban precinct, the reality it represents is hugely significant. Tribal communities in India represent a relatively independent section of a caste-based society. Their loss of control over forest lands, which traditionally provided them the economic basis of social independence had a huge impact on their lives. Today all statistics on poverty are actually framed by a community based angle and the scheduled tribes constitute one of the lowest indicators in terms of economic status. And yet, they are at the forefront of political resistance in different parts of the country. Within the larger narrative of tribal India, the potency of even gentrified, over-exposed art forms from the Warli community tell something about the complexity of social life in India.

Warli art has historically been showcased on the walls of their homes. The stylized images are powerful expressions, and their simplicity only enhances the meanings conveyed. Bodies that are slightly bent express motion, arms and legs may consist of only a few lines but communicate much more.   The paintings are a way of telling stories and depict scenes of everyday life, mythological stories, events expected in the coming year, or just entertainment. The Warli style of painting is said to date back many centuries and may have migrated all the way from Africa. Today, many people have moved to the city of Mumbai and scenes of everyday life in this dense city are very different from the old paintings.


Warli paintings representing daily life in the village.

Later this year, probably in September, we are planning a one week event in which young people can learn Warli art. Warli artists will come and teach children, teenagers, and students how to tell stories of their own life in attractive drawings and paintings, a bit like in cartoons. At the end of the week, the paintings will be brought together in an exhibition which will show everyday life in Dharavi as seen by today’s young generation.

The event is about connecting art and everyday life. Warli painting will be connected to the city, and youngsters will learn an art that once was part of the life of their own family. It is about making connections between the city and tribal, the present and tradition.

It goes without saying that the exhibition will be opened with a great celebration in which all participants can proudly present their achievements to their friends, families, and the community. Although the event is primarily educational, the artists will have a good time too as Dharavi is an extraordinary place to make paintings of.


Cybercafe and city-style furniture

The images in this post are made by artists of the Adivasi Sahaj Shikshan Pariwar Center in Masvan Palghar. Their art work is a source of income from which the center can finance its activities: education, healthcare support, social forestry and farming, and women empowerment.

The event will be organised in a close cooperation of local schools, Warli artists, URBZ, and the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Lausanne. Contact Sytse de Maat for more information.

Post by Sytse de Maat, PhD student in architecture at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Lausanne, and Urbzman.

  • Print this article!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • FriendFeed
  • Live
  • MySpace
  • Reddit
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Twitter
  • Turn this article into a PDF!

Homegrown Workshop: Jan 8-13, Mumbai/Goa


MG Road, Dharavi, Mumbai

The Homegrown Neighbourhoods workshop (Jan 8th-14th, 2013) looked at social and urban development processes in Mumbai. It involved a four day period in Mumbai exploring neighbourhoods and meeting people with whom we are working with  – mainly in Shivaji Nagar (Govandi), Uttkarsh Nagar (Bhandup) and our office in Dharavi. This was followed by a three day reflective and discussion based session at the institute office in Aldona, Goa.

This workshop saw the participation of friends and colleagues from various institutions around the world including the Tata Institute of Social Sciences, the Swiss Polytechnic Institute of Lausanne, the Politecnico do Torino, the Max Planck Institute of the Study of Religous and Ethnic Diversity in Goettingen, Columbia University and Harvard. It kicked off a collaborative research project aimed at producing critical concepts that can be used as tools of engagement for a pragmatic yet humane urbanism. By the end of the year we hope to have a series of essays exploring related themes in depth in various contexts and forms. We also hope that this collaboration will result in the organization of more workshops, studios and seminars with students and participants from Mumbai and other parts of the world.


First day session at the URBZ office in New Transit Camp, Dharavi, Mumbai.


Professor Amita Bhide who teaches at the School of Habitat Studies, Tata Institute of Social Sciences, and is an advisor to the Institute of Urbanology.

This was a significant moment for our ongoing work. We could reflect with academics and researchers from all over the world about themes close to our practice and deepen our engagements conceptually and intellectually. As practitioners we are acutely aware of how valuable the discursive space is and we were lucky to share experiences and ideas with a group of people that understands the spirit with which we work.

The Mumbai chapter involved explorations of “homegrown neighbourhoods” (the term which provides the title) in small groups and many discussions on the move. Participants could observe, discuss, critique and respond first hand to the contexts that shaped the themes of the workshop. The themes emerged from our ongoing work and the resource persons in Mumbai were essentially our local partners with whom we interact on an everyday basis.


From the Left: Pierre Frey (author of Learning from Vernacular), Vincent Kaufmann (Director of LASUR), both professors at the Swiss Polytechnic Institute of Lausanne (EPFL). From the right: Bhau Korde (social activist in Dharavi), Himanshu Keny (resident of Koliwada in Dharavi) and Matias Echanove (URBZ/Urbanology).


Centre: Irfan Khan community leader in Baiganwadi (Deonar-Govandi), explaining the mosque project to the workshop participants. Left and Right: Rahul Srivastava and Shardul Patil (URBZ/Urbanology).


Luca Pattaroni (Professor at EPFL) reading palms to children in Bhandup.

The intense sessions of observation, immersion, dialogues, became the fodder for the sessions in Goa. The office of the Institute in Aldona was formally inaugurated through the workshop. Debates about the informal and formal divisions  that shape most  perspectives on urban spaces today were critiqued and argued around threadbare, the concept of the tool-house was given the treatment by fire and the complex realms of economic activities and spatial arrangements – resonating at abstract and concrete levels – occupied much thought.  What was particularly rich was the perspectives that came from  the range of disciplines the participants represented, and the conversations across the Francophone and Anglophone social science realms.

The workshop is a start of a series of collaborations between the participants who will continue to interact and communicate with us to deepen, sharpen and critically evaluate the concepts and ideas that shape our practice. From April onwards, we shall be putting up short blog posts that frame the themes and ideas discussed and  emerge from these ongoing discussions. These broadly center around the idea of the tool-house, which acts as a touch-stone for building bigger theoretical frameworks on cities and urbanism.


Smita Srinivas and Yehuda Safran,  professors of urban planning and architectural design at Columbia University respectively. Both are also advisors to the Institute of Urbanology.


Discussion at the Institute of Urbanology in Aldona, Goa. From left to right: Anush Kapadia (lecturer in social science at Harvard), Michele Bonino (Prof at Politecnico do Torino & principal architect at Studio Marc), Sytse de Maat and Tobias Baitsch (PhD students at EPFL), and Ajay Gandhi (Post-Doc anthropologist at Max Planck Institute).


Gabriela Santana (architecture student at Escola da Cidade, Sao Paulo and member of URBZ Brazil)

We are particularly thankful to Vincent Kauffman and Luca Pattaroni, from Lasur, EPFL who provided the basic infrastructure and also bought in a big group from their institution. To Peter van der Veer of the Max Planck Institute for supporting the attendance of their members, to Mark Wigley Dean at the Graduate School of Architecture and Planning, Columbia University, for supporting the participation of Yehuda Safran and Smita Srinivas, and to all our friends who came on their own.

We are grateful to our advisor, the writer Amitav Ghosh who so generously opened his house to welcome the guests in Goa and whose intellectual contributions that evening remained with us all through the sessions the next two days.

Photos by Julien Gregorio. More photos of the workshop here.

  • Print this article!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • FriendFeed
  • Live
  • MySpace
  • Reddit
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Twitter
  • Turn this article into a PDF!

Paraisopolis-Dharavi News Update

http://www.vimeo.com/39823519
This video cannot be viewed in India because the Dpt of Telecom is currently blocking vimeo.com

We are on a backlog of news from Sao Paulo. Here is a nice video by the collective LiveinSlums (Milan/Nairobi) summing up the Sao Paulo Calling event in Paraisopolis, which we are part of. It is in Portuguese, Spanish and English with Italian subtitles! This pretty much covers more than a decent amount of the world from where people got involved in the project. Milan, Sao Paulo, Mumbai and other cities dialogued with each other, with the favelas of Sao Paulo being the focus and point of inspiration. What is heartening is that the connections we evoke between our work in Dharavi, Mumbai and Paraisopolis, Sao Paulo seem to have became a distinct new arc in this multi-city story. A short feature was also aired on SBT Brasil yesterday: Click here to see it.

It was picked up and presented as an article published in BBC Brasil about what Mumbai could learn from Sao Paulo. It mentions our project for a Paraisopolis-Dharavi Institute of Urbanology next year. This institute began as a speculative exercise, a piece of fiction. For us, fiction is all about creative possibilities that are waiting to happen. It propels us into making new realities and conjuring them up is only the first step towards their actual realization. The Institute is tentatively visualized as a program in which urban practitioners of all kinds – architects, planners, activists and artists among others – from all over the world, come and learn from the residents, local builders, contractors and others from the neighbourhood of Paraisopolis. They learn about construction techniques, local architecture and several other aspects of urban life which are of relevance to people all over the world. Look out for future updates on this page.

Click here to see in on the BBC website and here to read a google translation of the article in English.

Click here for a direct link to the article. And here for an English translation.

  • Print this article!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • FriendFeed
  • Live
  • MySpace
  • Reddit
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Twitter
  • Turn this article into a PDF!

Dharavi Goes to Paraisopolis


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.

Our obsession with mixing and merging urban landscapes and histories just moved to another level. We decided to let go of photoshopping for a bit and actually take a piece of Mumbai to Sao Paulo.

As part of the Sao Paulo Calling Exhibition curated by Architect Stefano Boeri and organized by the Secretariat de Habitaçao de Sao Paulo, images from Dharavi (Mumbai) became a part of the streetscape of Paraisopolis (Sao Paulo).

Residents of Paraisopolis chose pictures that appealed to them and in some ways corroborated their life, location or scenario across these two neighbourhoods that exist on either side of the globe.

Residents will exhibit them in their homes, shops, streets so that passers by can get a glimpse of the neighbourhood that is both so far away and astonishingly close in spirit. This live mashup continues to do what our mashed-up images always did – reveal connections across cities, to show they often emerge from similar impulses. From street vendors, to retailers, from residents to travelers, the neighbourhoods of Paraisopolis and Dharavi share as much in common as their distinct histories allow.

Together they represent the default mode in which the world is urbanizing when it is not being tamed by master planners and real estate developers. As we have shown in previous mashups there is no reason to view locally driven urban development as illegitimate. In fact, it is the acceptance of these local dynamics that have produced the celebrated heritage fabric of Italian old towns and the futurist urbanscapes of Tokyo’s suburbs.

That look of surprise and recognition, when people from Paraisopolis first saw the Dharavi images transformed into powerful gestures of solidarity as they lovingly chose their preferred image and stuck it firmly inside their worlds.

It was like a warm heartfelt handshake across thousands of miles.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.


Paraisopolis artist Barbela and Dharavi activist Bhau Korde. Click on the image to enlarge it and here to see the photo being exhibited.

  • Print this article!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • FriendFeed
  • Live
  • MySpace
  • Reddit
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Twitter
  • Turn this article into a PDF!

Paraisopolis Institute of Urbanology


Paraisopolis (Sao Paulo) viewed from the street.

URBZ is back in action on the streets of Sao Paulo! We are participating in an exhibition and cities-exchange event between Sao Paulo and 6 cities around the world. Initiated by Elizabete França, the director of the Secretaria da Habitação de Sao Paulo (which oversees more than 50 projects in various favelas) and curated by Italian architect Stefano Boeri, Sao Paulo Calling invites practitioners from Mumbai, Baghdad, Rome, Medellin, Nairobi and Moscow to 6 favelas in Sao Paulo to present their work, organize workshops and meet residents and community leaders. The event was launched last month at the Centro Cultural São Paulo and then at the favela of San Francisco.

rahulmatiascole-sanfranciscoSP
Rahul, Matias, Cole at San Francisco (Sao Paulo) last month.


URBZ senior adviser, life long Dharavi (Mumbai) resident and social activist Bhau Korde on the streets of Paraisopolis.

This weekend Mumbai meets Sao Paulo in Paraisopolis. We came with a special guest from Mumbai, Bhau Korde who has been a source of inspiration and guidance to the URBZ team since its inception. He will engage in debates and discussions with residents of Paraisopolis, this coming Saturday and Sunday. In addition, we are organizing a street exhibition on Dharavi, displaying 40 large posters showing scenes of every day life throughout the neighbourhood. We are also organizing a 3-day workshop on local construction practices with students of the Escola de Arquitectura de Sao Paulo. The students will be studying houses built by local masons (pedreiros) in Paraisopolis and learning directly from them. As part of our Dharavi-Paraisopolis exchange we are also proposing a Paraisopolis-Dharavi Institute of Urbanology to be held next year, where architects and public servants come and learn from residents (see poster).


Click to enlarge the poster and to read the text in English.

  • Print this article!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • FriendFeed
  • Live
  • MySpace
  • Reddit
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Twitter
  • Turn this article into a PDF!